Collapse Into Now

7.5/10

  This ended up being the final R.E.M. album as they announced their breakup shortly after it came out.  I think this ended up being a good album to go out on.  It doesn't do anything innovative whatsoever, but it succeeds in sounding like an R.E.M. album.  All the classic elements are here from the jangly guitar to the Mike Mills backing vocals and most of the songs could have easily fit on other albums.  It serves as sort of a career retrospective in a way, with certain songs being really reminiscent of earlier works.  In many cases this wouldn't be a positive thing but for R.E.M. this far into their career and as their last album, it's kind of what you're looking for.  It's like R.E.M. comfort food or something.

They start off right off the bat with a couple of high energy uptempo songs that wouldn't have been out of place on Accelerate.  One gets the sense that they're still trying to assure you that they haven't slipped back into their Around the Sun style.

The acoustic guitar driven Uberlin really invokes Drive from Automatic for the People without quite being a straight ripoff.  The way Stipe sings the verse with the pauses in between words is really similar to the way he delivered the verses in Drive.  I definitely get the impression this similarity is purposeful and is supposed to kind of put you in the mindframe of Automatic.  The chorus, which is quite nice, goes in another direction entirely.  So it really is a different song, you see.

Later you get the ballad Walk it Back, which sounds like it could have fit on any number of albums from Out of Time to New Adventures in Hi-fi.  It's immediately followed by the aggressive rocker Alligator Aviator Autopilot Antimatter, which could have been on Monster, New Adventures, or maybe even Document.

Final track Blue invokes the hell out of E-Bow the Letter with the spoken word lyrics and atmosphere.  They even went so far as to get Patti Smith to sing backup vocals again.

The album as a whole contains a nice mix of uptempo and slower songs, as well as acoustic and electric arrangements.  The melodies are pretty consistently solid throughout.  To my ears there are no obvious weak links here.  While I can't in any way say this is among their best albums, they most definitely did not drop the ball for their final album, which is kind of a relief in and of itself.

Looking back at their extensive catalog, they definitely have released a high number of above average to really good if not great albums.  Is that enough to put them into the pantheon of classic bands?  In my opinion, yeah, it is, even if I'm not as obsessed with them as I once was.  I don't think I would consider them my favorite band anymore.  My tastes have shifted a little more towards noisy psychedelic stuff, but I always appreciate good melodies and R.E.M. has long delivered those.  I'm also quite aware that I have a fairly strong personal bias towards this band just because they came along at the right time for me.  That said I think their classic albums have stood the test of time well.  I think new generations will continue to discover and enjoy R.E.M. for awhile at least.