Around the Sun

5.0/10

  The critical consensus seems to be that this is the worst R.E.M. album of all time.  Unfortunately I have to agree with that assessment.  The thing is, it's not horrible or irredeemable, it's just kind of bland.  Taken individually I don't really have a problem with any of the songs, but they're all kind of the same mid-tempo ballad.  There's not a lot of variety on display here and it gets to sound really samey after awhile.  They've done albums in the past that maintain an overall sound to them.  Automatic for the People was largely acoustic while Monster featured the same distorted guitar sound on many of its tracks.  Even Murmur sounds largely of a piece.  It's just the sound they chose this time isn't very interesting.  It's kind of like Automatic-Lite.  Plus the arrangements are just a little boring.  There's not much in the way of electric guitar to be seen and while there are some synths present, they seem to always remain in the realm of "tasteful."  But tasteful isn't what this album needs.  It needs some energy and some diversity.  It needs some more Mike Mills backing vocals.  It ultimately just kind of sounds like they weren't very inspired this time around.

  The thing is I think most of these songs are salvageable.  Like I said, taken individually I don't think they're all that bad, but they're just too similar in sound to each other.  If they had increased the tempo of a few songs or added some more interesting bleeps and bloops to the background it really would have helped.  Plus, like the last few albums, it's too long.  It's kind of a chore to sit through, which makes it feel really long.  Only two songs top the five minute mark this time, but a lot of them are above four minutes still.

  It honestly starts out promisingly enough.  Leaving New York is probably the best song on the album and I dig the part near the end where Stipe is singing different parts of the song at the same time.  So far so good, right?

  Electron Blue is next and it's not really a bad song at all, but it just doesn't seem like it's bringing anything new or interesting to the table.  Still, it's pretty good so not all hope is lost.  After that we get the Outsiders, which is mostly notable for featuring Q-Tip rapping at the end.  The thing is they already did the guest-rapper thing back on Radio Song from Out of Time.  And at least in that song it seemed more integrated to the song as a whole.  Here it feels more tacked on to the end and gimmicky.  And it's not even a new gimmick.

  This kind of seems to start a downward spiral as we get track after track that just sort of fails to impress.  I kind of like High Speed Train a little more than a lot of the other tracks, but it's not enough to right what's kind of a sinking ship.

  Around the Sun really isn't overtly terrible, but in a way that's sort of worse.  I kind of wish it was just a piece of crap unmitigated disaster.  Instead it's just sort of lodged firmly in the middle of the road.  James Taylor could have released this exact same album in 2004 and I wouldn't have blinked an eye.  That's what makes it kind of depressing.  I'd still rather listen to it than the majority of crap that's foisted upon the public, but it's really just a solidly average album from a band that used to be consistently well above average.  I will also allow that this is probably the R.E.M. album that I've listened to the least number of times, so it's possible that it's some kind of grower.  I don't really know it as well as I know their classics and I have difficulty distinguishing a lot of the songs or remembering how they go after the album finishes.  As it stands, I don't hate Around the Sun, but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone and I definitely would steer newbies away from this one.